GERMANY - 2024/09/25: In this photo illustration, a smartphone with the logo of short video sharing ... More
There’s been a lot of noise this week about YouTube Shorts “view count inflation.” But let’s be clear: this change is more about optics than impact.
YouTube’s new policy, effective March 31, shifts the definition of a view to match what already exists on TikTok and Instagram Reels — counting a view the moment a video starts playing or replays. Superficially, this makes creators look like they’re getting more views. But here’s the catch: the actual amount of time audiences are spending watching Shorts isn’t changing. It’s the definition that’s looser.
If this sounds familiar, it should. It’s straight out of the Facebook playbook.
Back in 2015-16, Facebook aggressively promoted video by showcasing eye-popping view counts — sometimes millions per video. But these were often just impressions, far removed from the meaningful 30-second views that YouTube required on long-form content. It inflated the sense of reach and engagement, misleading creators and advertisers alike. YouTube, ironically, is now adopting the same strategy — repackaged for Shorts.
So, What Exactly Changed?
Previously, YouTube counted a Shorts view only after a few seconds of watch time — not as long as the 30 seconds required for long-form videos, but still enough to filter out a meaningless scroll. Now, a view is counted the instant a video plays. If it loops (as Shorts often do), each new cycle counts again. This change brings YouTube into alignment with TikTok and Reels, which also count any autoplay as a view.
On paper, it means creators will suddenly see much higher view counts. But that’s not because they’ve cracked the algorithm or created better content — it’s because YouTube moved the goalposts.
Importantly, YouTube is preserving the original metric under a new name: “engaged views.” This is the stat that matters — not just for creators trying to build real audience relationships, but also for monetization. Revenue sharing and Partner Program eligibility will still be based on engaged views.
Why This Change Is Strategic — But Misleading
YouTube says it made the change in response to creators asking for better visibility into how often their content is seen. That’s partially true — but it’s also a smart move to make YouTube Shorts look more competitive.
Short-form is a battleground. TikTok remains dominant in culture and viewership. Reels is Instagram’s answer. Shorts, while growing, has always had a comparative optics problem — creators would often post the same video across platforms and notice YouTube’s view count lagging. The new metric closes that gap — but without fundamentally improving performance or audience quality.
In other words: it’s a perception shift, not a product shift.
This change also simplifies storytelling for creators when pitching brands. It’s easier to say “this Short got 100k views” than explain “it had 40k meaningful views, 100k impressions.” That has real implications for brand deals and CPM negotiations — but risks creating a new layer of noise and vanity metrics in the creator economy.
What Creators and Advertisers Should Actually Focus On
Engaged views. Watch time. Audience retention. These are the real indicators of whether content is working.
For brands looking to partner with creators, the key is to go beyond headline view counts. The real value comes from creators who can consistently engage and influence — not just stop a thumb-scroll for half a second.
For creators, this change means your view counts might spike — but your real task remains unchanged: make content that holds attention. Metrics like average watch duration and click-through rate on YouTube remain far more valuable for understanding your impact and potential earnings.